Would you know if you ate poisonous puffer fish? - The World from PRX (2024)

SAN FRANCISCO — When a Chicago couple grew dangerously ill two years ago after eating a home-cooked fish dinner, Canadian scientists figured out what had sickened them by using a new genetic test.

The test is designed to identify animal species based on subtle variations in a single gene. Dubbed the “barcode of life,” it provides a fast, cheap alternative to sequencing the entire genome.

By applying this technique to a remnant of the dinner, scientists at the University of Guelph in Ontario discovered that the Chicago couple — who recovered — had dined on poisonous puffer fish that had been mistakenly labeled as a safe monkfish, according to a report in a scientific journal.

“The incident showed regulatory authorities, especially the U.S. Food & Drug Administration, that DNA barcoding could be useful in food safety investigations,” said Robert Hanner, a biology professor at the Biodiversity Institute of Ontario at the University of Guelph, where the test was performed. Would you know if you ate poisonous puffer fish? - The World from PRX (1)“Now we are trying to make barcoding easier to use in the field, so fish inspectors and buyers can catch such errors in advance,” Hanner said.

Guelph has been a leader in the Consortium for the Barcodes of Life, an international effort to develop this quick, precise way to differentiate species. Formed in 2004, the consortium includes hundreds of scientists from 43 nations.

The barcoding technique targets a single gene located in the mitochondria, the energy-producing region of the cell. This gene appears to be active in all living things and consists of 648 base pairs of DNA. Each species arranges that short snippet of DNA differently, which makes it a useful genetic marker to identify “birds, butterflies, fish, flies and many other animal groups,” as scientists explain on a website about DNA barcoding.

The consortium has been gathering tissue samples and doing the laboratory work to isolate and sequence this barcode gene and match it to various animal species. So far, genetic tags for more than 60,000 species have been deposited in the Barcodes of Life database that serves as the consortium’s global repository.

Though barcoding is primarily a research tool, Hanner said it has started to find real-world applications such as helping air safety investigators identify birds that collide with jets during take offs and landings.

“Once a bird gets sucked through a fuselage it’s pretty hard to tell what it was,” Hanner said. The barcoding technique can identify the type of bird from tissue samples retrieved after the accident. “When you know which species was involved you can change the vegetation around the air field to minimize the chance of future strikes,” he said.

Hanner said the first big commercial application for barcoding is likely to be making sure that fish are correctly labeled — and not just for safety reasons.

“Fish comprise the largest component of protein in the human diet globally, and fish stocks are under great pressure,” he said, adding that studies have shown that fish are often mislabeled for reasons that range from error to fraud.

Last year, for instance, when the United Kingdom’s Food Standards Agency used DNA barcoding to test fish sold at catering houses throughout the country, it found that 10 percent was mislabeled. Would you know if you ate poisonous puffer fish? - The World from PRX (2)In its report, the agency said the declining availability of popular cod and haddock due to overfishing had increased “the potential for economic gain by substituting more expensive fish species with less expensive ones.”

Biotech scientist Mary McBride with California-based Agilent Technologies worked with U.K. officials on that barcoding project. “Once the head and the fins are removed it becomes very difficult to do a species identification of fish,” she said.

McBride said the goal is to develop devices to automate DNA barcoding so the technique can be performed outside of the academic laboratories in which it evolved. Ideally a food inspector or fish buyer would take a tiny fish sample and drop it into a testing kit rugged enough to be brought into the field, yet sophisticated enough to perform the many steps involved in extracting the barcode gene and using it to identify the species.

“We’re not yet in the marketplace,” McBride said.

But Hanner said barcoding technology is evolving rapidly as academic and biotech scientists work to simplify the process.

“Right now we can do the test for a few dollars a sample,” he said. “To be used by industry we have to get it down to pennies,” which he estimated could take another few years.

Would you know if you ate poisonous puffer fish? - The World from PRX (2024)

FAQs

How do you know if you have been poisoned by a puffer fish? ›

Symptoms generally occur 10-45 minutes after eating the pufferfish poison and begin with numbness and tingling around the mouth, salivation, nausea, and vomiting. Symptoms may progress to paralysis, loss of consciousness, and respiratory failure and can lead to death.

What happens if you eat a poisonous puffer fish? ›

A person experiencing pufferfish poisoning will totter or stagger when attempting to walk. Before long, sensory paralysis, slurred speech, and difficulty breathing will occur. Blood pressure will also drop. Thereafter, total body motor paralysis will occur and the sufferer will become unable to even move a finger.

What is the most poisonous part of a pufferfish? ›

The liver was served as a traditional dish named fugu-kimo, being widely thought to be a tasty part, but it is also the most poisonous, and serving this organ in restaurants was banned in Japan in 1984.

How many people have died from pufferfish poisoning? ›

Science Direct reports that Japan sees around 50 deaths related to pufferfish poisoning yearly. Most are contributed to inexperienced chefs who prepare the dish themselves like Gomes.

Can you recover from puffer fish poison? ›

Signs/Symptoms

Death may occur as early as 20 minutes, or as late as 24 hours, after exposure; but it usually occurs within the first 4 to 8 hours. Patient/victims who live through the acute intoxication in the first 24 hours usually recover without residual deficits.

How do you know if my fish have been poisoned? ›

Fish gasping for air at the water surface could be a sign of nitrite poisoning. Nitrite enters the bloodstream of the fish and binds hemoglobin cells – the oxygen carrying vessels of the fish's body. In other words, high nitrite levels will suffocate the fish.

What is number 1 in most poisonous fish? ›

Examples. Species of puffer fish (the family Tetraodontidae) are the most poisonous in the world, and the second most poisonous vertebrate after the golden dart frog.

How to make puffer fish safe to eat? ›

You can eat the outer skin when cleaned and blanched but there is great skill involved in removing the spines: hold the skin in one hand and slice them all off with a knife in one movement. Remove the eyes. Now gut your fish. Be very precise with your knife because the ovaries and liver contain most of the poison.

Can you touch a dead puffer fish? ›

The pufferfish's skin is covered in spines and spikes, which are exceedingly hazardous. Carry a toxin called tetrodotoxin (TTX), which is deadly to other fish and humans. You should avoid touching a pufferfish, especially if it is "puffed out." Your hands could be damaged and you could die.

Can you survive a puffer fish sting? ›

It has 13 spines on its back. that can even pierce the soul of a shoe. If you step on one, its venom will immediately paralyze you, and you could die from cardiac arrest or drowning. And even if you survive, the venom remains in your body for a month.

Why do people eat pufferfish? ›

Thrill-seeking is not the only reason that Japanese pufferfish remains so popular - aside from its distinct, subtle flavor and unique chewy texture, fugu is also low in fat and high in protein. Both fugu skin and meat are used in Japanese cuisine, and the meat is very versatile.

Can pufferfish be eaten raw? ›

Pufferfish are considered a delicacy in Japan, often eaten raw as sashimi or cooked in soups. But if the fish are not carefully prepared they can be deadly.

Who was the couple poisoned by puffer fish? ›

An elderly couple died after eating poisonous pufferfish. Their daughter wants stronger laws to prevent others from dying. A husband and wife in their 80s have both died after unwittingly consuming pufferfish in Malaysia. The couple's daughter is calling for stricter laws around the sale of the fish in Malaysia.

How many Japanese died from eating puffer fish? ›

Approximately 50 people die of puffer fish poisoning in Japan every year. Cases of death are also found in Hong Kong, Singapore, and Australia. TTX intoxication is also frequently reported from some cities in China. Episodic cases have been documented in the US.

What fish is more poisonous than cyanide? ›

Almost all pufferfish contain tetrodotoxin, a substance that makes them foul tasting and often lethal to fish. To humans, tetrodotoxin is deadly, up to 1,200 times more poisonous than cyanide. There is enough toxin in one pufferfish to kill 30 adult humans, and there is no known antidote.

What happens if you get poked by a puffer fish? ›

The pufferfish's skin is covered in spines and spikes, which are exceedingly hazardous. Carry a toxin called tetrodotoxin (TTX), which is deadly to other fish and humans. You should avoid touching a pufferfish, especially if it is "puffed out." Your hands could be damaged and you could die.

How is poison removed from pufferfish? ›

The egg sacs of the fish are pickled for three years to remove the poison before eating.

What does a puffer fish sting look like? ›

Pufferfish stings are more spread out. The marks are irregular with a cluster of raised sores. Anemone stings are similar but more tightly clustered. They sometimes develop blister-like sores that ooze.

What to do when stung by a pufferfish? ›

To treat a sting:
  1. Call triple zero (000) and ask for an ambulance.
  2. Get help from a lifesaver or lifeguard if possible.
  3. If the person is unconscious, start cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR).
  4. Pour or spray vinegar onto the sting for at least 30 seconds.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terrell Hackett

Last Updated:

Views: 5987

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terrell Hackett

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Suite 453 459 Gibson Squares, East Adriane, AK 71925-5692

Phone: +21811810803470

Job: Chief Representative

Hobby: Board games, Rock climbing, Ghost hunting, Origami, Kabaddi, Mushroom hunting, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Terrell Hackett, I am a gleaming, brainy, courageous, helpful, healthy, cooperative, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.